Wednesday, April 25, 2018

Chapter 16



Chapter 16
If you can empty your mind of all thoughts
your heart will embrace the tranquility of peace.
Watch the workings of all of creation,
but contemplate their return to the source.
All creatures in the universe
return to the point where they began.
Returning to the source is tranquility
because we submit to Heaven’s mandate.
Returning to Heaven’s mandate is called being constant.
Knowing the constant is called ‘enlightenment’.
Not knowing the constant is the source of evil deeds
because we have no roots.
By knowing the constant we can accept things as they are.
By accepting things as they are, we become impartial.
By being impartial, we become one with Heaven.
By being one with Heaven, we become one with Tao.
Being one with Tao, we are no longer concerned about
losing our life because we know the Tao is constant
and we are one with Tao.
================================================================
When people taste power and glory, they feel the huge boost to their ego and wish to hold on to that feeling of invincibility. Once you taste its intoxicating effects, it is hard to hold back or accept your downfall when you do experience such a setback. Nobody can accept his fallen grace readily. As for myself, I’m merely a minion and haven’t been close to such honors. But I can do imagine what it would feel like to be seated in a position of glory, for there were times that I thought (maybe very mistakenly) I was a better man than some of my friends in a small circle of my social relationships.
When I was young, my uncle used to tell me that at school it is usually the previously highest performing kid that kills himself and not a guy that cares whether he receives low marks on exams. A kid that is indifferent to his school performance could not care less about whether he does well or poorly on exams. On the other hand, another kid that his parents have high anticipation for lives under constant stress and pressure for having to not only satisfy himself and his parents but also to prove his uniqueness and talent to others. I do not think it is wrong to yearn for excellence. Nietzsche would precisely encourage you to cultivate yourself and strive for excellence. Nevertheless, it is better to become able to live as an ordinary man enjoying relationships with his  ompanions than to continue to despair upon having fallen from grace, should we choose between the two. Therefore, you do not have to kill yourself or become an alcoholic because of the failure that you define for yourself.
Let me try some “Laozian sidetracking” here. When I first got my job in Gangnam, Seoul, while I was still about to graduate college, I could not understand why my superiors worked so dearly to cling to their jobs. Why do not care and worry less for yourself, I thought. I could read from their faces that they were constantly worried about being fired and anxious to check whether everything was right. I will not explain in detail here why I had to leave my first workplace only after a year as a rookie. However, I will say that in hindsight I realized that they had a reason to feel nervous and even occasionally panicky and paranoid. It was precisely their anxiety that enabled them to stay in their position for over a decade. They knew that at their age they could not find a better job to replace the current one. They had kids and family to take care of, and so dreaded losing their jobs. Me, on the other hand, was relatively free from such concerns, so I acted however I wanted.(Not that I did not live under pressure because I also often felt like vomiting while having dinner alone alienated from those teammates.) I did not know I was being so naïve and even daring in that tense work environment. People also seemed to care about our boss’s approval. In fact, if they did not care as much about their employer’s view of them and how well they were doing at work, they would have already lost their lucrative job and been downgraded to some menial job elsewhere. The intense pressure that they put themselves under actually made them survive. The irony was that they so much hated having to spend long hours in the office and wanted to leave the workplace but did whatever it took – even including playing some dirty tricks on others (I was one victim) – to protect their place. I could smell in their stink their ugly desperation to drive out whomever they did not like as a new comer in the workplace; that made me feel like punching in their selfish dirty face. (For the record, I will say that now I thank them for teaching me a lesson and having considered me to be a target worthy of their political attack. I still consider those years spent in the business built and maintained through their tears and toils to be some of the prime moments of my life.)
A person that does not think he has anything to lose cannot accomplish anything. Here, I am not talking about a guy in a “deathground” mode. A person that cannot appreciate the value of something so much as to risk even his life and tranquility for it may never be able to attain it, unless by some tremendous luck he comes to have it. In some sense, you should be real desperate like you are about to fall in hell to achieve anything substantial. A guy that is idle and does not care hard enough is unlikely to spend much time for work and may make his family members or friends financially suffer for his idleness. Therefore, I am not recommending sloth as an alternative to our contemporary neurosis.
It sometimes happens that a person who feels he has nothing to lose if it is all for this particular goal actually achieves tremendous success and makes his achievement a lasting legacy in history. Look at Napoleon or Renan Cortez. (However, for another sidetracking, it should also be noted that they are two of the very few that turned out to be successful; the rest of the other guys that took the gambling were wiped out at an instant.)
So much for my Laozian sidetracking.
Let me mention Marcus Aurelius, who was a mighty emperor of the then superpower, the Roman Empire. As the stoic writer Ryan Holiday notes, he constantly reminded himself to be humble and even referred to the teachings of the stoic guru Epictetus, who was once previously a slave, for guidance on maintaining his stoicism.In fact, stoicists encourage us to have a flying bird’s view of the ordinary world affairs. For example, the usual objects of our anger appear to be so petty once looking upon them from a distance.
Let us say that the above chapter of the tao te ching encourages us to expand that bird’s view even further into the universe itself. I do not think Laozi would have known this scientific fact then, but even the earth and heaven are not eternal. In Chapter 7, Laozi notes that they are eternal because they do not live for themselves. However, everything in the universe, or even the universe itself, is in a “constant state of flux.”
Greene notes in the last chapter of the 50th law that as you consciously bring yourself closer to the realistic idea of the possibility of death, you would be able to focus your energy more on things that truly matter and less on other trivial things that do you no good in the end. He also tells us to realize the sense of the “oceanic.” We are essentially one and the same, if contemporary cosmology is telling me right – because everything in the universe exploded from a single big bang point. If a man achieves this tranquil “aloofness,” he will not probably be harmed even after falling from grace.

Chapter 15


Chapter 15
The Sages of old were profound
and knew the ways of subtlety and discernment.
Their wisdom is beyond our comprehension.
Because their knowledge was so far superior
I can only give a poor description.
They were careful
as someone crossing a frozen stream in winter.
Alert as if surrounded on all sides by the enemy.
Courteous as a guest.
Fluid as melting ice.
Whole as an uncarved block of wood.
Receptive as a valley.
Turbid as muddied water.
Who can be still
until their mud settles
and the water is cleared by itself?
Can you remain tranquil until right action occurs by itself?
The Master doesn’t seek fulfillment.
For only those who are not full are able to be used
which brings the feeling of completeness.
================================================================
The Sage described in the above “poor description” by Lao Tzu is certainly far from an ideal lofty person looking down on his neighbors from atop an ivory tower. I don’t have any intention to disparage a Confucian sage, but it is my belief that a practitioner of Confucianism is prone to fall in the error of developing condescending attitudes towards non-practitioners; this is like several Jehovah’s Witnesses condemning “foreigners” for not following their doctrines. As a matter of fact, I believe that Confucius’ intent in itself was innocent and pure because the only thing he ever wanted was to establish order and bring lasting peace and stability to families and society. Nevertheless, it cannot be denied that Confucianism as an organized effort –especially, as in the case of medieval Korea, or Chosun – was an utter failure. Confucius himself was a good Master; he personally reminds me of an oriental stoic sage. He even said, “What the superior man seeks is in himself; what the ordinary man seeks is in others.” (I like this quote.) Just as the majority of the sects of Christianity now and then severely distorted the original teachings from Jesus, the later self-proclaimed followers of Confucius also distorted him or at least failed to realize the real intent of his teachings. They instead clang to their dogmatic interpretations of Confucius and were, most of the time throughout Korean history, incorrigible hypocrites. They were rigid and inflexible. Their attitudes were somewhat similar to the European Catholic priests of the dark ages. They are geniuses at rhetoric. I believe a current psychologist can rightly diagnose them to have suffered personality disorders. The scary thing is that they truly seemed to have believed they were good people. No ordinary person has the ability to think they are good people while destroying the spirits of others. They were like the Jon Jones’ of our community – some pathological liars and deceivers having no scruples. There was something about these thick-skinned characters that deeply maddened and frustrated good ordinary people.
Some may suspect I am all against Confucius. That is not true. I certainly have a decent respect for the man. In some way, he reminds me of Nietzsche in that he persevered to the end in the mission of morally perfecting himself and society despite cold responses from people.
Now I will turn to Lao Tzu. If one confines Lao Tzu to a sage that practices wu-wei and only stays away from a mess; and contrasts Lao’s “idleness” with the unending zealous efforts of Confucius to correct a corrupt society, one will see only one facet of Lao Tzu. My renewed version of Lao Tzu, however, is a sage that embraces even that Confucius. This renewed Lao Tzu embraces both the conventional Lao Tzu and Confucius. Such a Lao Tzu would know when to be a conventional Lao Tzu or Confucius.
“Who can be still until their mud settles and the water is cleared by itself? Can you remain tranquil until right action occurs by itself?”
The above quote illustrates a beautiful metaphor illustrating the wu-wei philosophy of the tao te ching.
However, as much as I do really appreciate the beauty of this metaphor (I emphasize this again, I really love the muddy water metaphor), I need to add qualification to Laozi’s metaphorical advice.
In Chapter 2, I stated as a possibility a case in which one may achieve inner piece by harmonizing himself between the conscious and the unconscious by putting faith in the self-correcting power of the self. Lao Tzu compares this autonomous power to natural purification of water that is made to remain still. A river or sea has the ability to get clean by itself.  Likewise, a depressed patient – although it is highly advised that he should take antidepressants and consult a psychiatrist – may also heal after a long, long period of time.
However, I must say that there are cases where mental, psychological pain never disappears. You may even have to continue to carry this heavy load on your mind throughout your lifetime. If that is the case, instead of waiting for the pain to disappear, you may have to learn to exist in relation to this perpetual pain, like Sisyphus narrated by Albert Camus. There are moments when your pain feels insurmountable. There doesn’t seem to be an exit. In fact, the more you wait for the muddied water to purify by itself, the longer it takes for your unconscious to work it out (this is my “psychological theory of relativity,” which is not really difficult to understand based on common sense). You may or may not be able to heal from your trauma or immense emotional pain that weighs you down. Nobody can tell.
As for myself, I think about this constant nagging noise. What noise? The literal noise. I am allergic to noise and hate every unwanted noise – especially, the loud noise from people that I am not acquainted with, noise from cars on the street, noise from the motorcycles that I wish I could flip over, noise from an airplane in the sky, noise from the people next door, noise from the pulses in my earlobe which are made audible when I put my ear-plugs as I try to fall asleep, noise from my coworker in the next cubicle constantly chatting with her colleagues, and especially, noise from that goddamn repugnant printing machine in the office. It pains me. I am not kidding. All these noises are extreme irritations to my life, and I do seriously believe that they are taking a heavy toll on my cardiovascular health. In fact, I am not able to urinate at ease in the bathroom when a different person is making sound in a bathroom for the other gender's use. I sometimes have minor heartaches because of stress coming from noise and people. You may think I am an erratic, easily irritable person.  I am. But this recognition does not help me any better. I even thought about consulting a doctor taking some pills that can kill down my nerves. But I am worried about their side effects so haven’t tried one. It turns out that the only sound that cures me is Linkin Park’s instrumental and Chester Bennington’s voice – along with some other alternative rock music such as Limp Bizkit.
Why am I talking about noise? Personally, I do not believe that I am able to grow immune to noise. I have suffered this since I was about fifteen and things never got better for me. There were several occasions of arguing with my neighbors which could have escalated into a violent altercation. When I lived with a roommate in my freshman year at college and could not fall asleep because this guy would constantly make noise while playing a computer game, this guy once asked me, “Haven’t you got used to all this?” I did not tell him this then, but I never got angrier with him than that. Noise is constantly wearing down my inner peace, piece by piece. It hasn’t improved at all. Likewise, if some psychological problem is constantly nagging you and hasn’t improved even a little since a long time ago, perhaps we may have to rethink if this water metaphor can work for you. You may begrudgingly have to accept that this is your fate. In other words, you must learn to exist your pain. We all have thorns in the flesh as Apostle Paul did. Do not fight it. The more you fight it, the stronger it binds you. Do not wait for it to disappear, either. Befriend it. The previously muddied water, even after having been “cleared by itself,” is more likely to get muddy again as time goes by. This is, I believe, a way of practicing our amor fati.

Chapter 14


14
Look for it, and it can’t be seen.
Listen for it, and it can’t be heard.
Grasp for it, and it can’t be caught.
These three cannot be further described,
so we treat them as The One.
Its highest is not bright.
Its depths are not dark.
Unending, unnameable, it returns to nothingness.
Formless forms, and imageless images,
subtle, beyond all understanding.
Approach it and you will not see a beginning;
follow it and there will be no end.
When we grasp the Tao of the ancient ones,
we can use it to direct our life today.
To know the ancient origin of Tao:
this is the beginning of wisdom.
=======================================================
So far from chapters 1 to 13, I have tried to analyze the content of the tao te ching from a logical perspective. However, the more I read through the chapters of the book, the more I find Laozi’s statements to be primarily mystical. Of course, I am aware that Lao Tzu did have insights into nature, and based upon them, he unfolded his core ideas.
In the last verse of the chapter, Lao Tzu encourages us to know the “ancient” origin of Tao. Whereas Solomon declares in Proverbs that to learn to to fear Yahweh is the beginning of wisdom, Lao Tzu asserts that it is the knowledge of the tao’s origin that will empower us to attain wisdom. But what Tao really is is subject to one’s interpretation. In addition, one’s interpreted tao is not quite the Tao of the universe. Therefore, it is essentially vain to attempt to define it. Because you can never quite reach it.
Because Lao Tzu never clearly identifies the identity of the tao, it is difficult to discern what he precisely meant to tell us. Hegel rightly notes that while Lao Tzu’s book contains many profound maxims, most of them cannot be understood clearly due to their ambiguity. The tao te ching does include a lot of elements that lead one to make a mystical interpretation of the text.
In that sense, it is no wonder that many ancient Chinese people developed mystical faith in the transcendental power of Tao, which led to the religion of Taoism. Mysticism is not found only in Asia; it pervaded Western societies as well. In fact, mystical beliefs are still observed among many of our contemporaries. As a matter of fact, even Wittgenstein’s first published monumental book ended in mystical notes – i.e., concluding that we should only remain silent regarding things we cannot describe but only experience.
Actually, I have a feeling that some of the descriptions in Chapter 14 can resonate very well with someone seeing fantasies after taking LSD. I will put here a bold guess simply for fun. Is it possible that Lao Tzu included in his book some descriptions of his fantasies after taking opium?

Saturday, April 21, 2018

Chapter 13



Chapter 13
Success is as dangerous as failure,
and we are often our own worst enemy.
What does it mean that success is as dangerous as failure?
He who is superior is also someone’s subordinate.
Receiving favor and losing it both cause alarm.
That is what is meant by success is as dangerous as failure.
What does it mean that we are often our own worst enemy?
The reason I have an enemy is because I have a “self”.
If I no longer had a “self”, I would no longer have an enemy.
Love the whole world as if it were your self;
then you will truly care for all things.
=======================================================
“Success is as dangerous as failure,and we are often our own worst enemy.”
The above quote couldn’t be more true. How often do we observe in history the best talented generals rush themselves to ruinous choices or tactical mistakes because of their ego?
When Ronda Rousey suffered a crushing defeat to Holly Holm, she could not believe that she lost the fight. Not that I think that she did not really think that she could in her wildest imagination lose to somebody. She knew the possibility of losing for sure. But when a loss did really materialize, her ego was on the verge of total breakdown.  She literally wanted to kill herself for a moment. The only thought that dissuaded her from this self-destructive suicidal thought was that she should marry her boyfriend and have his children. She was on a consecutive win streak like no other competitor in her division. This division was meant to be her ruling ground until the day of her voluntary retirement. But all the adulation and hype surrounding her prevented her from contemplating deeply an aftermath of any possible loss. In other words, she failed to be a “Stoic” before that loss. Maybe you think that a fighter has to envision only a glorious outcome of a fight event (as does a self-indoctrinated Conor McGregor) because imagining an opposite scenario would make him feel insecure. Nevertheless, wins and losses are part of our lives (Greene mentions this in the ending strategy chapter the 33 strategies of war). Personally, I am not a fighter and am only a fan of MMA, so I do not know her emotional pain. It would be presumptuous to say that I could understand her feelings. She was an astonishing champion, and I personally believe that her legacy is still intact despite her losses (she lost another championship fight afterwards). But none of that soothed her damaged pride. Many of us would rather want to be a fallen Ronda Rousey than an ordinary person having accomplished nothing. Nevertheless, she had to suffer a devastating pain of accepting the losses.
Although she’s probably emotionally recovered now, her story serves as a reminder for us: our ego can be very fragile because of the whimsical character of our fate. In many cases, our successes are transient and should not think they will last as long as we expect. Holly Holm, who dethroned Ronda Rousey – and was deemed to be a future superstar that would last for a very long time – lost her first title defense fight against Miesha Tate, who had lost two fights against Ronda Rousey.
Repeated successes can blind our sight. If anything, your humility should be based on recognition of this transient nature of your successes and gains and not on condescension. As bantamweight fighter Michael McDonald notes, you own nothing in this universe. This is a very stoic attitude. You think you own your cars, your body, and everything. But you had nothing when you came into the universe. Everything was simply granted to you. You essentially earned nothing by yourself. Are you good-looking? You were simply given your looks from your parents. Did you accumulate wealth working days and nights? Your effort is estimable, but society ultimately gave you your riches. Upon time of your death, they will all be taken away.
If we should take a cautious attitude to our lucky gains, then what are we going to make of our repeated failures? I do not know the answer. In some respect, however, I regard Amy Purdy to be an exemplary case of overcoming one’s misfortune. My admiration for this beautiful woman (both in her charms and mental power) does not stem from my pity for her loss of two legs. Personally, I am not confident that I could recover or even hope to recover as well as she did if I suffered the same accident. She has shown enormous fortitude and courage that not even many ordinary males can show. If we can find one practical role model of Nietzsche’s dictum, “Live your life as a work of art,” I believe that she is the one. If you see her TED talk, she doesn’t by the way look like some firm, determined, grave woman. She is convivial, jolly and optimistic in a “healthy” way.
Greene notes in the preface of the 48 laws of power that a person aspiring to attain power should learn to bide his time because grass will eventually grow if you give it enough time. I can see his point, but I can see the most miserable people in the world that suffer innumerous tragedies without a single good luck happening to them. This is disturbing especially in that while fortune does not allow us luck forever, there are obvious cases of unending pain in several people’s lives.
It is already difficult enough to accept our personal miseries or admit that in many ways we are“inferior” to our friends and acquaintances (especially because of the spread of our private lives through social network services). However, as I indicated in one of the above chapters, it is in principle possible to direct our attention to some of the better things about ourselves and guide our unconscious to change for the better in the long run.
However, overwhelming physical pain due to terminal illnesses, losses of one’s family members, and a lot other factors – these are the things that totally break one’s will to live. Your pain subdues and consumes you. You cannot win this game. You are done. Period. A person suffering ongoing excruciating pains has no room to make conscious efforts to feel good about himself. I do not know what can possibly save him. From an empirical point of view, it is clear that there are no perpetual “successes” in our lives; however, there does exist a series of “failures” that are doomed to continue like curses from God. When Job in the old testament suffered enormous pains in the hands of Satan, he heroically proclaimed that he wouldn’t blame God and said bad things might occur to him just as well as good things did. Nevertheless, if it is certain that, despite all our efforts for a considerably long period of time, certain ones among us will suffer indefinitely with never-ending pains that completely devour them, then the only way out – as much as I regret to say this – may be to tolerate suicide as the last resort. But, most of the suicides that we read on newspaper were mistakes, I believe.


Chapter 12



Chapter 12
Five colors blind the eye.
Five notes deafen the ear.
Five flavors make the palate go stale.
Too much activity deranges the mind.
Too much wealth causes crime.
The Master acts on what she feels and not what she sees.
She shuns the latter, and prefers to seek the former.
=======================================================
“The Master acts on what she feels and not what she sees.”
It is difficult to understand[]this quote. I will try to approach it from two points of view.
In the 50th law, Greene notes that our perspectives should be based on realism than our idealistic notions. Your idle fantasies about your future will not help you in this competitive world, he argues. If the Master or sage really acts on his “feelings” instead of daring to see the reality, wouldn’t this be tantamount to perilous ignorance?
If, however, Lao Tzu meant to say that he values mental/spiritual matters over material possessions that we can visibly see, then this may make sense.
Nevertheless, based on the above English translation of the chapter, I am not sure what it is like to “act” on what he feels. Because, according to the translation, this most likely indicates that he acts based upon what he feels – i.e., the actions that he takes are based on how he feels and not what he objectively sees.

Chapter 11


Chapter 11
Thirty spokes are joined together in a wheel,
but it is the center hole
that allows the wheel to function.
We mold clay into a pot,
but it is the emptiness inside
that makes the vessel useful.
We fashion wood for a house,
but it is the emptiness inside
that makes it livable.
We work with the substantial,
but the emptiness is what we use.
=======================================================
In the 33 strategies of war, Greene notes that it is unwise to overstay your presence. If you leave a debate with somebody at a sensible timing before culmination of the conversation, it leaves room (which is the “emptiness”) for further anticipation and he will come to desire your presence in future.
In addition, rather than attempting to fill in every vacancy of a person’s thoughts or correct every fallacy of his ideas, it may be a better idea to indirectly question him on his false notions – rather than forcefully arguing your points – and allow him to take care of his problems on his own. In this regard, it can be argued that the tao te ching puts great emphasis on “autonomy.”It may look risky to put a state of affairs to a chance, but a reasoned way of letting “it” be will usually work better than trying to rectify every supposedly wrong situation. Every counselor must heed this advice. That you should trust the self-correcting power of the person you are dealing with. Your purpose is to guide the person, not dictate his thoughts. Who do you think you are? You are no different mortal person than he is.
Personally, I can hardly recall anybody that tried to help me in that way. Every single one of them was assertive, and I did not appreciate their advice very much. Ultimately, regardless of their true intents, their efforts only aggravated my relationships with them.  I only grew resentments towards them. Although I cannot deny that there were several moments afterwards in my life that I felt there were several truths in what they said, I do not think the way they spoke helped me very much. Mostly, their main interest was in proving themselves right rather than trying to be a caring person. If they had to choose between proving themselves right and feeling superior, and being ready to be proved to be wrong for my benefit, they would choose the former.
When I was a teen way younger than now, they wouldn’t spend a penny more for me in a social gathering place. Their behaviors contradicted the apparent intent of all their bullshit.
I find this attitude highly repellent. Some of them justified their rude “advice” to me by saying that they would never have said those things in the first place if they did not care enough about me. They said saying bullshit is better than showing complete indifference. I disagree. In fact, it would have been far better for them to leave me be and take care of things myself. Their unsolicited advice and interference only annoyed me, and I still have bad memories of them. I find them despicable. I want them out of my life.
A truly caring person will show respect for you instead of talking with domineering attitudes. He will accept your individuality and try to compromise between himself and you. Even if it is obvious that you are seriously flawed in some respects, the person will not throw those things directly in your face. He will patiently wait and try to only sow the seeds of improvement in your personality and leave the rest of the job to your autonomy.


Chapter 10



Chapter 10
Nurture the darkness of your soul
until you become whole.
Can you do this and not fail?
Can you focus your life-breath until you become
supple as a newborn child?
While you cleanse your inner vision
will you be found without fault?
Can you love people and lead them
without forcing your will on them?
When Heaven gives and takes away
can you be content with the outcome?
When you understand all things
can you step back from your own understanding?
Giving birth and nourishing,
making without possessing,
expecting nothing in return.
To grow, yet not to control:
This is the mysterious virtue.
=======================================================
In fact, when you make it explicit that you want something in return for a favor that you may do to your child, friend, colleague or anybody else, people’s sense of gratitude will blow away. The more you talk about your contributions/accomplishments, the cheaper person you become.
Even if they look ungrateful to you, you cannot be harmed if you already thought you wanted nothing in return. Your joy was in the deed of doing what you could do for them and not in the anticipation of earning something from them afterwards.
Therefore, a respectable parent would want nothing more from his child than to see him grow in full independence. This is the exemplary parent that the child can look up to.

Chapter 9



Chapter 9
It is easier to carry an empty cup
than one that is filled to the brim.
The sharper the knife
the easier it is to dull.
The more wealth you possess
the harder it is to protect.
Pride brings its own trouble.
When you have accomplished your goal
simply walk away.
This is the path way to Heaven.
=======================================================
In the ancient political environments, there was something unstoppable about having power. Once you acquired power, you had to maintain it because letting your power slip away to the hands of others including your rivals meant death. In a case like this, one would not be able to “walk away” simply because he “accomplished” his goal. They could not walk away because their survival depended on maintaining power. Suppose however that they would not have had to deal with this concern in the first place if they had not set foot in the bloody arena of politics. In this case, it should be noted that in the old past it was the most innocent neutral ones that were sacrificed in the hands of bloody Machiavellian psychopaths. The hardest thing to do is stop wisely after having decided to entangle yourself with some mess that won’t let you go away easily.
Therefore, although I do not doubt the efficacy of being “light-loaded,” some may reasonably doubt for how long your tranquility can last. Think about the ancient nomads. They had no enduring settlements and wandered about aimlessly. Naturally, they could not have achieved any great civilization.

Chapter 8



Chapter 8
The supreme good is like water,
which benefits all of creation
without trying to compete with it.
It gathers in unpopular places.
Thus it is like the Tao.
The location makes the dwelling good.
Depth of understanding makes the mind good.
A kind heart makes the giving good.
Integrity makes the government good.
Accomplishment makes your labors good.
Proper timing makes a decision good.
Only when there is no competition
will we all live in peace.
=========================================================
“Assume formlessness,” said Greene in his last chapter of the 48 Laws of Power. In fact, none of the existing formulas can work if you do not understand the subtleties of your situation and the timing that you should execute those plans. When the cold principles of power are applied to the letter without contemplation, you will be put in a disastrous situation. You cannot be that naïve.
In one of the above chapters, I took the example of technical analysis in the share investment market. If I remember correctly, there are algorithms developed by PhDs in computer science and mathematics that constantly learn the evolving stock market behaviors and precede, in anticipation of future behaviors, any other individual market participant. There may be patterns, but they are not perpetual. You must evolve with fluidity of water.
“Only when there is no competitionwill we all live in peace.”
Slingerland, who authored a book on the concept of wu-wei, asks in his book why science was not possible in China. If we remove competition entirely by following the above quote, there will be indeed no advancement in technologies.I cannot say that there was no “competition” at all in ancient China. China was even once in what we call the “Warring States period.”
It is clear that you cannot force people to stop competing against each other. It is ingrained in human nature. Look at the case of North Korea. This country is unlike any other contemporary society and is a brutal regime that kills down the very instincts of every member of the society. In this horrible, bizarre[]country, competition is banned by suppressing people’s autonomous market behaviors. This is no peace. This is equivalent to an ongoing experiment of total annihilation of basic humanity.
If peace ever arrives by doing no competition, this must be a case in which both competing states come to realize and agree upon that more competition will only bring about a ruinous result to both parties.
Arguably, a moderate degree of competition is beneficial. For example, instead of driving away competition from schools as in the case of a former US administration concerning public school education - which would lower students’ academic performance – we must allow students to aspire to achieve higher performance through competition – but not excessive competition.

“It gathers in unpopular places.”
The tao may not hesitate to stay in unpopular places and garner attention from the disadvantaged. Is this necessarily good? As much as far-fetched this sounds, I doubt whether a prostitute readily giving away the availability of her flesh to those willing to pay her money can in any good sense be called a good person.



Chapter 7



Chapter 7
The Tao of Heaven is eternal,
and the earth is long enduring.
Why are they long enduring?
They do not live for themselves;
thus they are present for all beings.
The Master puts herself last;
And finds herself in the place of authority.
She detaches herself from all things;
Therefore she is united with all things.
She gives no thought to self.
She is perfectly fulfilled.
=========================================================
This chapter reminds me of Jesus’ saying that the first will be the last and the last the first.
However, a person that does not take proper care of himself– whether it be in a workplace or on a battlefield – would not last long. In fact, it is easy to exploit a person holding a naïve view that by being generous to the others he will be in the end appreciated for his efforts.
It is highly unlikely that a person that does not appreciate your efforts right now will one day appreciate you in the future.
If we should find exceptional cases of one thanking the other’s sacrificial devotion, they may be mostly found in parent/child relationships. It usually happens that the grown old child fully realizes only belatedly his departed parents’ exclusive devotion and care that made him what he is today.


Chapter 6



Chapter 6
The spirit of emptiness is immortal.
It is called the Great Mother
because it gives birth to Heaven and Earth.
It is like a vapor,
barely seen but always present.
Use it effortlessly.
 =========================================================


I am not sure how we can use emptiness. Is Lao Tzu indicating a perpetual motion machine?
Nietzsche notes that if we can murder God and thereby dethrone Him, this should be a source of happiness and not despair. Absence of absolute standards does not mean nihilism, but instead creation of a background upon which we can become supermen and make artworks of our lives. Derrida similarly notes that differance initiates infinite possibilities of word play and writing.
As such, instead of seeing an element of terror in vacancy and nothingness, we turn to its positive side and create some meaning out of it. This may be another way of practicing amor fati.

Chapter 5



Chapter 5
Heaven and Earth are impartial;
they treat all of creation as straw dogs.
The Master doesn’t take sides;
she treats everyone like a straw dog.
The space between Heaven and Earth is like a bellows;
it is empty, yet has not lost its power.
The more it is used, the more it produces;
the more you talk of it, the less you comprehend.
It is better not to speak of things you do not understand.
==================================================
“Heaven and Earth are impartial; they treat all of creation as straw dogs”
As Greene notes in the 50th Law, the universe couldn’t care less about your fate. The world is indeed a brutal place. Even when you are luckily exempted from the brutal violence of natural disasters that strike others, there is still a problem: the creeping boredom. David Foster Wallace once said that one that can take care of boredom can achieve almost anything. Boredom seems to be a sign that you are living in prosperity. Greene writes that the ancient Roman aristocrats were bored, so they amused themselves with morally depraved entertainments. Even when things are going well with us, it is as if our unconscious would create new problems like boredom to make us suffer. The starving or suffering people that are of interest to Laozi, if they suddenly prospered with riches, might have become Letzter Mensch posited by Nietzsche.
It is better not to speak of things you do not understand.
When Wittgenstein proclaimed that there is nothing we can talk about ethics a priori, Karl Popper spoke against the idea and stressed the role of a philosopher. Perhaps Wittgenstein is one of the few thinkers that agree with Laozi on this point. That we can hardly talk about the metaphysical.